Wed 17 Jan 2007
The idea of a public service bureau is an enchanting to me.
Posted by Paul Krush under Crowdsourcing , Mass CustomizationWhen I use this term service bureau for jewelry I mean a company that makes clients wax models from the 3D file they provide. The idea that a service bureau would share these files online does not exist in the jewelry industry currently. All service bureaus are private as they can command much higher rates for keeping their client’s work private.
When I say a public service bureau I mean a company that shares clients designs on the Internet for all to see and download.
Public service bureau (PSB) possibilities:
- Over time a PSB would create a database of designs for other people to use.
- It would create a community of users using and improving other people’s designs.
- Such a service could create a competition among users further motivating people to use the service.
- Some people are will be motivated to send in files just to create an online portfolio.
- Some designers will just want their models used by others.
- If the public service bureau was efficient and could profit from the content of the users the price per model could be reduced or even free.
- Advertising and promotion expenses could be very low due to word of mouth.
The motivation for clients to send in files would need to be huge. Some people would see this as giving away their work, and never use a PSB. Others would see the service as a fun experience, and just plain valuable. The service will grow if the model price is low enough and there is a critical mass of users. It’s all theory now, but I am going to invest some serious time and money into testing these ideas.
This is not the same as a discount service bureau. Creating the models would be an experience for the users. People will upload design because it’s a fun experience. This is the same as tom sawyer convincing everyone painting the fence was fun. It’s win-win for everyone.
Similar working concepts:
- A lot of websites have users successfully uploading content (YouTube, Blogs, MP3 sharing sites, etc).
- It’s a little like watching the paper photos come out at the developer. (I’m dating myself)
- Some jewelry sites post pictures of past work.
- It’s like a watering hole. Free water for all, and it makes a good place for conversation.
- A PSB is like an Internet forum that content (writing, pictures, files, etc) is uploaded for the moment, but retains value over the years.
- I want to say it’s like a 3D model sharing service but I don’t see any great examples of this yet with models for manufacturing.
- This is like shoppers willing to have their buying habits recorded in exchange for discounts on products, AKA grocery store discount cards.
What would a public service bureau need to survive?
- An easy to use system of uploading and sharing files.
- A way to fight the tragedy of the commons problem.
- A way to keep out spammers.
- A well maintained forum for users.
- The service has to be fun to use.
I think a public service bureau set up right would really grow as it’s database and user base grows. Change a low enough price and users have no other option but to use the service. I see such a service being used by the Pro-Am jewelry making community.
Theory is great, but some people experienced in the trade have to be shaking their heads at me. Yes there are a lot of issues with this. This is why I am starting tests with the simplest part I can, a half-dollar size coin. Changes will be made on the fly. It’s going to be fun to get this concept off the ground so others can copy us. I just want to see this happen, and I am compelled to do it.
March 2nd, 2007 at 2:56 am
Aloha Paul,
Thank you for doing this…I am a very beginner in Rhino and cad cam apps. I just bought an mdx-15 with a 4th axis. I will send you files once a start producing them. Thnx again and b well, Neil
April 9th, 2007 at 7:32 pm
Hello Paul,
I stumbled across your site and find it very interesting. I am not a jeweler in the traditional sense, but I do all the same things, just to a different end.
I create handmade writing instruments (fountain pens and rollerball pens). I design my own pieces in Jewelsmith and Rhino, cut the wax models with my 4-axis Sherline, and then cast in silver or gold.
Since I have all the equipment, I have thought about trying my hand at some rings and other jewelry pieces. I downloaded some of your models and plan on playing with them a little.
Thanks for taking the time to build this site and share some of the knowledge.
I would be happy to make contributions to the site.
Regards,
Ralph Place
Dallas, Texas
April 12th, 2007 at 3:04 am
Hello Paul,
What a nice idea, Im a 3D Software Specialist at the same time R&D, we are also the distributor of Roland Machine. We use JWX-10, MDX-20/40/650, I also used different CAD/CAM Software, and my objectives are to share my knowledge and ideas for better digital future.
i-macs Galicia
Manila, Phillipines